One
Send your order
Add the flavors and quantities you want to your cart, then tell us where they're going.
Baked to order in Maine
Maine Whoopie Pies
The official state treat of Maine, made the way it ought to be — two soft cake halves the size of your hand, filled thick and eaten over a napkin. Every whoopie pie is $5 and baked to order in small batches.
Order whoopie piesThe flavors
Six to choose from, plus seasonal
Traditional is the one people grew up on. The rest came out of the kitchen over the years and stayed.
Maine whoopie pie
Traditional
Classic Maine chocolate whoopie pie with vanilla filling, hand-sized.
$5 each
1
Maine whoopie pie
Maple
Maple whoopie pie with maple buttercream, made with Maine syrup.
$5 each
1
Maine whoopie pie
Maple Walnut
Maple walnut whoopie pie with toasted walnuts folded through the filling.
$5 each
1
Maine whoopie pie
Pumpkin with Cream Cheese
Pumpkin whoopie pie with soft spiced cake and tangy cream cheese filling.
$5 each
1
Maine whoopie pie
Red Velvet
Red velvet whoopie pie with cream cheese filling.
$5 each
1
Maine whoopie pie
Carrot Cake
Carrot cake whoopie pie with spiced cake and cream cheese filling.
$5 each
1
Seasonal whoopie pies come and go with the months — watch the Finch Journal or join the letter below to catch them.
How ordering works
Order online, we ship nationwide
Add the pies you want to your cart, tell us where they're going, and pay right here.
Two
Pay right here
Check out by card, Apple Pay or Google Pay — no invoice to wait for. A receipt comes to your email.
Three
We bake and ship
Whoopie pies are baked to order in small batches and packed for the mail once payment clears.
Good to know
Questions we get asked
What is a Maine whoopie pie?
Two rounds of soft chocolate cake with a sweet cream filling between them — closer to a cake sandwich than a cookie. Maine claims it as the official state treat, and ours are hand-sized, the way they're sold at a proper church supper.
How big are they?
About the size of your hand. One is a generous dessert; two is a decision you make on your own.
Can I mix flavors in one order?
Yes. Order any combination you like on the order form — every flavor is $5 each.
Do you ship outside Maine?
We ship nationwide. Tell us where they're going on the order form and we'll pack them accordingly.
Weddings, showers & gatherings
Whoopie pies for a crowd
Maine whoopie pies make an easy, memorable dessert table — birthdays, weddings, baby showers, holiday parties, and office events. We bake to order and pack them for pickup or delivery. Tell us the date, the head count, and any flavors you have in mind.
The Mercantile Letter
Notes from the workroom
Seasonal shop openings, new patterns, and what's rising on the kitchen counter. Sent quietly, never often.